Paranthropus jaw from Ethiopia’s Afar puts the ‘nutcracker’ hominin 1,000 kilometers north of its known range


A 2.6-million-year-old lower jaw from Mille-Logya in Ethiopia’s Afar region is the first Paranthropus fossil ever found there, a team led by Ethiopian paleoanthropologist Zeresenay Alemseged reported in Nature.

Fragments of the Paranthropus lower jaw MLP-3000 from Mille-Logya, Afar, with comparison jaws

The Paranthropus jaw MLP-3000 from Mille-Logya, top, and alongside other hominin jaws, bottom (Source: University of Chicago)

Paranthropus, nicknamed the nutcracker for its huge molars and heavy jaws, lived between about 2.8 and 1.4 million years ago. Its fossils had turned up from southern Ethiopia down to South Africa, and the northernmost until now was a skull from Konso. The new specimen, catalogued MLP-3000, lies roughly 1,000 kilometers north of Konso.

The gap had bothered researchers for years. The Afar has produced hundreds of fossils from more than a dozen species of Ardipithecus, Australopithecus and Homo, Lucy among them, yet no Paranthropus. “The apparent absence of Paranthropus was conspicuous and puzzling to paleoanthropologists, many of whom had concluded the genus simply never ventured that far north,” Zeresenay said in a University of Chicago release. Some blamed a diet too narrow for Afar conditions. Others thought early Homo had pushed it out.

The find itself came on January 19, 2019, when a local assistant handed Zeresenay a toothless piece of jawbone. “The first thing that struck me was its size,” he told New Scientist. The crown of a left lower molar was found the same day. The fragments went to Chicago, where micro-CT scans of the hidden tooth roots and the shape of the jaw confirmed the identification.

The team did not assign the jaw to a species. It combines the thick jaw and very large back teeth typical of Paranthropus with some older traits, so the paper lists it as Paranthropus sp. New Scientist reported that Paranthropus aethiopicus or Paranthropus boisei are the most likely candidates. Carrie Mongle of Stony Brook University, who was not part of the study, told the magazine there was “no question” it was Paranthropus.

Fred Spoor of the Natural History Museum in London, a co-author, said the supposed absence “was the result of an incomplete fossil record.” The sediments at Mille-Logya cover about 3.0 to 2.4 million years ago, a thinly sampled stretch of time when East Africa was turning to open grassland and the earliest Homo and stone tools appear. The jaw suggests Paranthropus could live in the same changing landscapes as Homo and was not simply crowded out.

Zeresenay, who teaches at the University of Chicago, is best known for Selam, the skeleton of a three-year-old Australopithecus afarensis child his team found at Dikika, also in the Afar, in 2000. His group has worked at Mille-Logya since 2012. The jaw was studied at the National Museum of Ethiopia in Addis Ababa under permits from the Ethiopian Heritage Authority.

Sources