News Analysis
Deadly Adwa day shows Abiy’s struggle to shift focus from divisive Ethiopian emperor
https://www.ethiopia-insight.com/2023/0 ... n-emperor/
16 March, 2023
Ethiopia’s socio-political tensions bubble over again in raging annual debate over external and internal colonialism.
Clashes between security forces and celebrants in Menelik II Square, Addis Abeba, resulted in
https://ehrc.org/regarding-2023-adwa-vi ... ntability/at least one death
and injury of civilians.
The 2 March incident occurred as security forces attempted to disperse a crowd gathered to commemorate the 127th anniversary of the Battle of Adwa between invading Italian forces and those led by Emperor Menelik II.
The recent violence spread to the nearby St. George’s Church, where followers of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church (EOTC) were celebrating a religious festival.
According https://ehrc.org/regarding-2023-adwa-vi ... ntability/ to the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission (EHRC), government security forces used
on peaceful gatherings of people around Menelik II Square and in nearby St. George’s Church.unnecessary and excessive force
The EHRC reported that the security forces’ actions resulted in at least one death and several injuries.
Similarly, the Addis Ababa Diocese of the EOTC accused https://www.facebook.com/AddisAbabaDioc ... LRKvnKmwMl security forces of violently disrupting a peaceful religious celebration and using tear gas on celebrants.
Venue Uproar
The government’s decision to move the celebrations from Menelik II Square to Meskel Square sparked widespread indignation among EOTC believers.2
The square hosts the emperor’s statue and is located near St. George’s Church of the EOTC, whose Tabot (Ark of the Covenant replica) was marched alongside the emperor’s forces and is said to have helped them win the war against the invading Italian army.
The drive to move the celebrations was seen by some as a concerted effort to de-emphasize the role of the Church and the emperor in the historic victory.
While not canonized by the Church, Menelik II is venerated https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FILRWFhVgAI ... ame=medium as a pious and benevolent emperor by many of the EOTC faithful.
EOTC leaders feel https://www.facebook.com/birhanu.tefera ... 199033422/ that the Church’s role as a spiritual guide in the monumental victory, as well as its overall place in Ethiopia’s socio-political history, has been under systematic attack https://www.ethiopia-insight.com/2023/0 ... ns-remain/ by Abiy’s government.
Consequently, EOTC leaders https://www.facebook.com/abaynehk/posts ... HpxmDQiyFl and its dominant Amhara socio-cultural base are indignant https://www.facebook.com/10005027002873 ... l/?app=fbl at the government’s perceived attempt to undermine the emperor’s legacy.
Disputed Ownership
Ethiopia’s triumph at Adwa was a monumental event that symbolizes African resistance to European colonialism. It represents a pivotal moment in Ethiopia’s history, in which the country’s diverse inhabitants banded together to fight a common enemy.
Over the years, the egalitarian nature of the victory allowed Adwa to become an all-inclusive foundation on which modern Ethiopian nationhood was built.
However, more recently, there has been a tussle to claim sole ownership of Ethiopia’s political history among the country’s competing ethno-nationalist elites. This has caused arguments to intensify over who should take credit for the Battle of Adwa.
Amharas tend to credit https://www.facebook.com/abaynehk/posts ... HpxmDQiyFl Menelik II, who was the King of Shewa, a territory that is now mostly part of the Amhara region, before becoming emperor of Ethiopia in 1889.
Oromo nationalists have emphasized https://www.facebook.com/14512941284167 ... l/?app=fbl the role of Oromo generals, such as Dejazmach Balcha Safo and Ras Gugsa Welle, in achieving the victory, disregarding the nationalist narrative about Adwa.
Many Tigrayans, for their part, note that the battle was fought in Tigray and claim the region’s leaders and inhabitants played a central role in the military victory.
Consequently, their commemoration https://www.facebook.com/TigrayCAB/post ... FTUBhcmcLl of Adwa has centered around Ras Alula and Bashay Awalom (he's an ERITREAN!!!!!), Tigrayan heroes of the battle, as embodiments of what they view as Tigray’s predicament of sacrificing the most but getting the least from the Ethiopian victory.
Divisive Figure
In the past, Emperor Menelik II was hailed as the main hero of Adwa. However, this view has caused consternation, particularly among Oromo nationalists, as he is a controversial figure due to his internal policies.
Menelik II’s bloody campaigns to expand the empire southwards in the late nineteenth century are bitterly resented https://www.ethiopia-insight.com/2022/0 ... ire-state/ by many Oromos and other southern peoples, making him a divisive figure.
Oromo nationalists, who view the territorial expansion of the Ethiopian empire and imposition of the semi-feudal Neftegna-Gabbar https://www.jstor.org/stable/525437 system as a form of internal colonization,
tend to portray Adwa as the clash of two competing imperialists.
In the words https://advocacy4oromia.org/article/the ... pretation/ of Tsegaye Ararsa, a prominent Oromo nationalist and legal activist,
Similarly, Tigrayan socio-political elites have increasingly challenged the traditional perception of the Adwa victory as a source of national pride and solidarity.it was a war fought between two maiden empires competing over the fate of black peoples in Ethiopia and beyond.
Emperor Menelik Addis Ababa Abyssinia reception of Theodore Roosevelt's Diplomatic Treaty Mission 1903-1904. Massillon Museum.
They have emphasized Adwa’s symbolic significance in cementing Eritrea’s separation, which contradicts the national narrative that portrays the victory as the foundation of unity.
Menelik II’s perceived decision in the treaties before and after the battle to bifurcate
Tigrinya-speaking people north and south of the Mereb by ceding Eritrea to Italy has made the emperor unpopular among Tigrayans.
A more nuanced view recognizes Menelik II’s leadership in achieving victory at Adwa while recognizing that history is complex and he was a man of his times.
Unifying Force?
Over the past three years, celebrations of the battle by Ethiopian nationalists while Adwa itself has been under siege https://www.ethiopia-insight.com/2022/0 ... ve-tigray/ and its residents subjected to unspeakable atrocities https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/20 ... y-eritrea/ amid the civil war have been viewed by many Tigrayans as rubbing salt in their wounds.
Government officials have claimed https://www.facebook.com/FDRECommunicat ... yH2gGsknZl that the recalibration of the celebration was motivated by a desire to
strengthen national unity and nation-building.
Abiy’s efforts to move the focus of the victory away from the controversial figure of Menelik II and towards emphasizing Adwa’s role in unifying all of Ethiopia’s nationalities appears to be part of a larger policy shift towards sustaining the multinational constitution as per the Pretoria Agreement. https://www.ethiopia-insight.com/2022/1 ... obi-deals/
While this move will likely be well-received by federalists, and may even contribute to an eventual consensus, it will continue to face stern resistance from Amhara nationalists and social conservatives in the EOTC, particularly as it’s accompanied by Abiy’s rapprochement with the widely despised TPLF.
Although the signs are bad, the National Dialogue Commission https://addisstandard.com/analysis-ethi ... ra-region/ may possibly still play a significant role in fostering a compromise, without which the country faces further instability due in part to these underlying historical schisms.