Mereja Forum

[Thomas H]

[Sam Ebalalehu]

Our Harvard educated friend, Samuel Lipoff, has some point, but he goes overboard. True, from the question one cannot accurately tell her age. The month she was born, and the questioners must factor in to come to the right answer. If Sameul stops right there, it would be splendid. No, he just chose to write the question in his own terms. He speculated the sister might have died. If she expired the questioner had no motive to hide it, and he let us know the fact. A person who answers a question has a right to point out a fallacy in the question, but not to assume so many scenarios regarding the question. In other word, he cannot rewrite the question.