Za-Ilmaknun wrote: ↑07 Aug 2020, 19:37
Sadacha Macca wrote: ↑07 Aug 2020, 18:59
Za-Ilmaknun wrote: ↑07 Aug 2020, 18:22
Sadacha Macca wrote: ↑07 Aug 2020, 17:48
This is typical of Amhara extremist-unionists, when they cannot think of other ideas or lies, they spread malicious propaganda, hoping that the white man, will once again come to their rescue under the guise of ''fighting off Islamists.''
Who committed the crimes then? What is the proof? Do you also acknowledge the crimes by amhara gangs in addis against oromos and oromo businesses? or do you pick and choose which crimes you want to acknowledge?
this is the root of the issue, people only want to acknowledge wrongs done by people of ''other'' ethnicities, while ignoring the ones committed by their ''own.''
I for one, have NO PROBLEM condemning wrong doings, whether it's done by a fellow oromo, or other than them. all should be equal in matters of justice and the law, despite the very sad and miserable history of ethiopia.
I for one, believe in holding INDIVIDUALS accountable, as opposed to BLAMING entire religious or ethnic groups for crimes.
Forget TPLF, we KNOW our history, and we know what the forces of menelik and co, did in our lands.
blaming tplf for that, is like blaming them for menelik's wrongs, it simply isn't just or right.
the fact is, the church blessed the massacres he carried out, and blessed him to usurp the lands of others, to doom them to perpetual poverty, and more.
taddesse birru, a christian oromo, alluded to this when he blamed the poverty of oromo farmers , could be blamed, on the misappropriation of their land by menelik and his clergymen, and he too, was killed, for his stance on the oromo cause, position in the empire, etc.
religion doesn't matter to amhara extremists, who hate ALL OROMOS regardless of their religion, especially if that oromo stands up for the rights of his nation.
yes human rights abuses take place daily, the vast majority of which are most likely being that of the army and security forces against civilians, mostly oromo civilians, as it's always been- the army massacring oromos, as they have been doing in wallaga for a while now, while you guys remained silent or justified by saying ''oh they are going after OLF, by killing innocent farmers, raping their women and so on, they do those crimes to go after OLF SHANE''...but you won't say that, because once again; it doesn't fit you narrative.
Sadacha Macca
First off, it is a good gesture on your part to be open to condemning crimes regardless of whoever the perpetrators are. That is human and that is what is lacking in the discourses.
There are countless YouTube clips and first hand transcriptions of the victims speaking about their ordeals. Most fanatical tribal adherents just glance the other way or try to find a false equivalence to neutralize the legit claims. That is the whole crux of the issue. When you try to attack someone there always is a push back or the instinct to defend oneself. When you go to kill, you may end up being the one killed. The Qerro in the middle of Addis came to do what it knows how to do best and, there was a backlash. Self defense, like I said before, is a criminal offence in Oromiya.
I agree with you that the security establishment isn't doing enough to protect civilians. It has been time and again proven that the tribal oriented security establishment is part of the problem too. It is however,the government's responsibility to make sure that professionalism and impartiality should be the standard to operate by. There is no trust on the security forces from every side because of how they are made and how they are functioning.
Whatever is happening in Wolega is the extension of this. Armed struggle is an outlawed activity that could invite a disproportionate response from those in power for it is a direct threat to their power. You are expecting us to act against the same government which is inundated with Oromo elites who are trying so hard to remake the country in Orommuma image? The power struggle between different Oromo factions is at best served well if left for themselves to sort it out. Inviting TPLF to stand with OLF will only bring the worst outta OPDO. OMN openly was agitating Qimants and Agews to eradicate amharas..and ya all were justifying it to date. The barrels of biltsigna ..ADP branch are always pointed at Fano and murdering them every day. ...and you have been crying about that too..weren't ya?
If you think that shortage of land is the critical problem in that country to have us murder each other..you better ask Karuturi global of Indian who was forced to lease a land the size of Arsi for almost free by the TPLF administration. If i start citing small historical blips to give credence to genocide that is happening in my generation, I sure must be out of the capacity to reason. We learn from history ...real history.. not to repeat them. It is shameful to stand with TPLF and wave its flag and sing "down down Ethiopia" before the wounds of those Oromo brothers who paid in blood and limbs healed.
Whoever harms even an innocent bird, or animal, should be held accountable-this is my position.
No one deserves as much as a hair on their head being harmed, simply because of the ethnicity they were born into, through no will of their own.
However, we have some amhara extremist activists, exploiting these horrible incidents and cases, to advance their political agendas and interests, basically benefiting from the blood of innocents. That too, should be condemned.
Then, you say it was qeeroo who started the incidents/problems in addis, when we know for a fact that, oromo businesses being targeted, for example, were not the business of qerroo's, but of oromo residents, who were not even politically active- but you are sitting here, trying to justify it, because... bingo! You happen to be an Amhara, and you want to make one side look like innocent angels, your side*, and make the 'other' side look like devils, the oromos.
objective, fair, and just activists, etc, seem to be missing in general from all sides, because loyalty to ones ethnicity tends to cloud people's judgements- whether it people like obbo halafifi from the tplf/tigray, or you and other amharas, or oromos. this is my take as an individual!
people also-tend to label an entire nation or ethnic group as being 'bad,' or 'inherently evil,' and so on and so forth; as opposed to blaming the individuals among them, which is the fair thing to do. but alas... silly humans are prone to generalizations. perhaps it's the ''negativity bias'' thing?!
what is occurring in wallaga, regardless of whose in power, is wrong. A Muslim scholar once said: wrong is wrong, even if the entire world is doing it, and right is right, even if only a few are doing it. adelem, ende? any religion, christian or not, can agree with that, wrong is wrong, always, regardless of the number of people doing it.
the LEAST one can do is condemn the acts of violence and rapes in wallaga, if you do not have the power, will, etc, to take sides with the oppressed.
can you show me where OMN advocated for a tiny minority, agew/qimant, to massacre a group who dwarfs them in numbers and weapons?
it's like saying we told the tiny birds in the animal kingdom to rise up and fight the lions and elephants-laughable at best.
nobody invited olf, they got involved, because they see it in their interests, the same way abiy saw it in his interests to sign military pacts with eritrea, to jointly fight tplf, olf, anyone opposed to their reign in the horn.
that's politics, unfortunately. people are driven, largely by interests and agendas, which are more often than not, wrong and based on the desire of humans for power, money, material gain, so on and so forth.
it's not a shortage of land that caused oromos to be poor under haile selassie, it was the taking of bulk of their lands produce through extortion, the gabbar-naftenya system, because the amhara elites were too lazy to work their own lands, or to work themselves, among other reasons.
you do not understand this, or even want to, because you do not want to acknowledge the crimes of your ''heroes,'' emiye menelik and others. you rather deflect, or deliberately distort the facts or etc...
we do not use the past to justify anything, but to remind those who forgot the history or wish to twist it to fit their narratives.