Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum

Kuasmeda
Member+
Posts: 6387
Joined: 26 Mar 2015, 08:47

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Kuasmeda » 24 Jun 2020, 06:41

Ohad Benami has also exposed the lies of TPLF. He said that no TPLF fighter participated in the war to liberate Massawa by EPLF. This is the time where TPLF will lose forever :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
pushkin wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 06:33

pushkin
Member+
Posts: 9536
Joined: 23 Jul 2015, 06:10

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by pushkin » 24 Jun 2020, 07:03

Their lies are exposed everywhere :mrgreen: :lol: :lol: :lol: :mrgreen:
Kuasmeda wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 06:41
Ohad Benami has also exposed the lies of TPLF. He said that no TPLF fighter participated in the war to liberate Massawa by EPLF. This is the time where TPLF will lose forever :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
pushkin wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 06:33

Ethoash
Senior Member+
Posts: 26144
Joined: 20 Apr 2013, 20:24

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Ethoash » 24 Jun 2020, 08:19

እናንተ ደደብ የስሜን አጋሜዎች ይቅርታ በኢጣሊያን ባወጣላቹሁ ስም ባለመጥራቴ።
ምን ያህል ደደብ ናቹሁ ውያኔዎች ቁጭ ብለው ነው እናንተን ያስገደሉዋቹሁ ማለት ነው ። በመጨረሻ ግን መላውን ኢትዬዽያ ተቀበሉዋቹሁ በጨበጣ። በጨበጣ ከድላቹሁ አላቀው ኤርትራን ብቻ ስጡዋች ሁና እነሱ መላውን ኢትዬዽያ ውስዱ ። ምን አነት ቂል ነው ። እኛ ነን የሞትነው ድርግን ለመገርስ ስ እኛ ነን የሞትነው ምፅዋን ነፃ ለማውጣት ግን ኢትዬዽ ያንን የተረከበን ወያኔ ነው ምንም ስው ሳይሞትባቸው ምንም ጥይት ሳይቶኩሱ ማለት የማንን ሞኝነት ነው ግልፅ አርጎ የሚያሳየው።

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

why r u afraid u need the entire Ethiopian army to fight one Golden region .. r u afraid? Chicken written all over this statement.....

army u might send him by force or because u pay him but war fought with heart and gut ..if the army have no drive they will not fight and win.. the oromo haver zero interest fighting war that is not their business .. this war belong to Amhara Amhara only if Dr. Abiy as he is fed government should keep his distance away from Amhara war cry .. if Amhara want a war that is their business let them have their war... if Eritrea want to join the buda that also green lighted .... now as war expert this is what will happened to u if u start war with Golden and lose ..Eritrea will lose her two port and become land locked .. and half Amhara land will be given to Sudan let the Amhara fight a war endlessly with Sudan they will live us alone...

u might ask how about Eritrea and Amhara win that is your business u know what to do.. but i am begging u not to lose their will be no mercy... this time around .... zero tolerance for resistance apply to golden side .. they will be total master of Eritrea and Amhara until they done with u.. never to cause any problem in future

Aurorae
Member
Posts: 635
Joined: 10 Nov 2019, 02:21

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Aurorae » 24 Jun 2020, 10:12

Agame boy,

Please.Green eyed agame, stop looking at Eritrean ports, Ain't going to happen. Both EPLF and TPLF leadership are still at the helm 30 years later. Both hate each other's guts. Both are determined to destroy each other. TPLF will start war under the guise of Eritrean opposition. That will put Isayas in a predicament. He will take the war to Meqele with Abiy's permission. Abby most likely will look the other way. If he doesn't, Isayas will have no choice but to make peace with the Eritrean opposition. Mark my word, Isayas will never let TPLF alone as long as he is in power. For peace to prevail, both leadership need to surrender power to the people whom they claim they liberated in the first place.

Sadacha Macca
Senior Member
Posts: 12335
Joined: 22 Feb 2014, 16:46

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Sadacha Macca » 24 Jun 2020, 13:53

Not necessarily. Shabia played the biggest role, and had the strongest anti derg army, but to say they alone beat the derg.... is not true.
it was a combination of things, such as, the low morale of the army due to stupid decisions made by mengistu, the various other rebel armies who weakened the derg too [OLF, TPLF, and so on], and other issues.
as far as tplf goes, they know better than to fight ethiopia. i would hope that the decent tigrayans would also realize this would hurt them more than anyone else.

Zmeselo
Senior Member+
Posts: 33606
Joined: 30 Jul 2010, 20:43

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Zmeselo » 24 Jun 2020, 14:11

I don't want to in anyway diminish the contribution of others in the fall of the dergue, but the overwhelming work & sacrifice was done by Shaebia. If Menghistu's most experienced & battle- hardened units weren't defeated in Eritrea (consisting of 6 huge offensives & 1 stealthy, the trench warfare of Sahel, the destruction of Nadew, the fenql offensive in Massawa etc), he wouldn't have any problems in pacifying Ethiopia by pulling his army southwards. Later too, the EPLF mechanized units' contribution within Ethiopia until the occupation of Addis was immense.

Besides, Menghistu himself is a witness to that fact!



Sadacha Macca wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 13:53
Not necessarily. Shabia played the biggest role, and had the strongest anti derg army, but to say they alone beat the derg.... is not true.
it was a combination of things, such as, the low morale of the army due to stupid decisions made by mengistu, the various other rebel armies who weakened the derg too [OLF, TPLF, and so on], and other issues.
as far as tplf goes, they know better than to fight ethiopia. i would hope that the decent tigrayans would also realize this would hurt them more than anyone else.

Sadacha Macca
Senior Member
Posts: 12335
Joined: 22 Feb 2014, 16:46

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Sadacha Macca » 24 Jun 2020, 14:24

Zmeselo wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 14:11
I don't want to in anyway diminish the contribution of others in the fall of the dergue, but the overwhelming work & sacrifice was done by Shaebia. If Menghistu's most experienced & battle- hardened units weren't defeated in Eritrea (considering of 6 huge offensives & 1 stealthy, the trench warfare of Sahel, the destruction of Nadew, the fenql offensive in Massawa etc), he wouldn't have any problems in pacifying Ethiopia by pulling his army southwards. Later too, the EPLF mechanized units' contribution within Ethiopia until the occupation of Addis was immense.

Besides, Menghistu himself is a witness to that fact!



Sadacha Macca wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 13:53
Not necessarily. Shabia played the biggest role, and had the strongest anti derg army, but to say they alone beat the derg.... is not true.
it was a combination of things, such as, the low morale of the army due to stupid decisions made by mengistu, the various other rebel armies who weakened the derg too [OLF, TPLF, and so on], and other issues.
as far as tplf goes, they know better than to fight ethiopia. i would hope that the decent tigrayans would also realize this would hurt them more than anyone else.

I'd say, a large portion of it, yes, but not all of it, nor would the toppling of the derg in ethiopia proper, have been possible without shabia coordinating its efforts with tplf, and others... hence the reason why they had an alliance, albeit tactical, with the TPLF. remember, it was tplf who helped shabia defeat jebha and push them out of eritrea, this was when tplf officially took badme, by replacing jebha there, btw, but shabia's top leaders, such as Obbo Isayas, overlooked it, due to the priority being handling the derg.

I believe the derg would've been defeated within Ethiopia, eventually, with or without shabia, simply because the people were growing more and more discontented with it... the masses play the biggest role in any revolution or struggle.... more so, than the soldiers.
you cannot rule a people who detest you, for long, especially in a place like Ethiopia. So, eventually, OLF, TPLF, and others, would have dismantled the derg within ethiopia.

simbe11
Member
Posts: 2087
Joined: 23 Feb 2013, 13:02
Location: Addis Ababa

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by simbe11 » 24 Jun 2020, 14:29

I like those highlighted and enlarged section of your post.
ELF/EPLF fought to death TPLF steals.
That is typical TPLF. Steal, loot, theft, corruption.
Nothing more.
But noe EPLF got Eritrea with 1000km coast line
TPLF got Tigrays' barren land (Temporarily)
Who is the loser????
Ethoash wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 08:19
እናንተ ደደብ የስሜን አጋሜዎች ይቅርታ በኢጣሊያን ባወጣላቹሁ ስም ባለመጥራቴ።
ምን ያህል ደደብ ናቹሁ ውያኔዎች ቁጭ ብለው ነው እናንተን ያስገደሉዋቹሁ ማለት ነው ። በመጨረሻ ግን መላውን ኢትዬዽያ ተቀበሉዋቹሁ በጨበጣ። በጨበጣ ከድላቹሁ አላቀው ኤርትራን ብቻ ስጡዋች ሁና እነሱ መላውን ኢትዬዽያ ውስዱ ። ምን አነት ቂል ነው ። እኛ ነን የሞትነው ድርግን ለመገርስ ስ እኛ ነን የሞትነው ምፅዋን ነፃ ለማውጣት ግን ኢትዬዽ ያንን የተረከበን ወያኔ ነው ምንም ስው ሳይሞትባቸው ምንም ጥይት ሳይቶኩሱ ማለት የማንን ሞኝነት ነው ግልፅ አርጎ የሚያሳየው።

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

why r u afraid u need the entire Ethiopian army to fight one Golden region .. r u afraid? Chicken written all over this statement.....

army u might send him by force or because u pay him but war fought with heart and gut ..if the army have no drive they will not fight and win.. the oromo haver zero interest fighting war that is not their business .. this war belong to Amhara Amhara only if Dr. Abiy as he is fed government should keep his distance away from Amhara war cry .. if Amhara want a war that is their business let them have their war... if Eritrea want to join the buda that also green lighted .... now as war expert this is what will happened to u if u start war with Golden and lose ..Eritrea will lose her two port and become land locked .. and half Amhara land will be given to Sudan let the Amhara fight a war endlessly with Sudan they will live us alone...

u might ask how about Eritrea and Amhara win that is your business u know what to do.. but i am begging u not to lose their will be no mercy... this time around .... zero tolerance for resistance apply to golden side .. they will be total master of Eritrea and Amhara until they done with u.. never to cause any problem in future

Zmeselo
Senior Member+
Posts: 33606
Joined: 30 Jul 2010, 20:43

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Zmeselo » 24 Jun 2020, 14:46

Sadacha Macca wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 14:24
Zmeselo wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 14:11
I don't want to in anyway diminish the contribution of others in the fall of the dergue, but the overwhelming work & sacrifice was done by Shaebia. If Menghistu's most experienced & battle- hardened units weren't defeated in Eritrea (considering of 6 huge offensives & 1 stealthy, the trench warfare of Sahel, the destruction of Nadew, the fenql offensive in Massawa etc), he wouldn't have any problems in pacifying Ethiopia by pulling his army southwards. Later too, the EPLF mechanized units' contribution within Ethiopia until the occupation of Addis was immense.

Besides, Menghistu himself is a witness to that fact!



Sadacha Macca wrote:
24 Jun 2020, 13:53
Not necessarily. Shabia played the biggest role, and had the strongest anti derg army, but to say they alone beat the derg.... is not true.
it was a combination of things, such as, the low morale of the army due to stupid decisions made by mengistu, the various other rebel armies who weakened the derg too [OLF, TPLF, and so on], and other issues.
as far as tplf goes, they know better than to fight ethiopia. i would hope that the decent tigrayans would also realize this would hurt them more than anyone else.

I'd say, a large portion of it, yes, but not all of it, nor would the toppling of the derg in ethiopia proper, have been possible without shabia coordinating its efforts with tplf, and others... hence the reason why they had an alliance, albeit tactical, with the TPLF. remember, it was tplf who helped shabia defeat jebha and push them out of eritrea, this was when tplf officially took badme, by replacing jebha there, btw, but shabia's top leaders, such as Obbo Isayas, overlooked it, due to the priority being handling the derg.

I believe the derg would've been defeated within Ethiopia, eventually, with or without shabia, simply because the people were growing more and more discontented with it... the masses play the biggest role in any revolution or struggle.... more so, than the soldiers.
you cannot rule a people who detest you, for long, especially in a place like Ethiopia. So, eventually, OLF, TPLF, and others, would have dismantled the derg within ethiopia.
The weyane contribution in the defeat of the ELF, eventhough there, is grossly exaggerated. Yes, some units consisting of approx. a thousand fighters participated. The ELF, for the most part fell, because of inner fructure. It opted from the beginning to be decentralized & its units divided on religious & tribal terms. That's why, most Elf-ites opted for exile; instead of staying put & fight the EPLF. The dissatisfaction with the leadership was huge amongst its ranks.

With that logic, we can add the contribution of the russians in aiding Menghistu as well. So much so, some of their generals and army leaders- were POW's in Eritrea.
One other issue easily overlooked is Eritrea's topography. Its mountainous terrain is very fitting, for a guerilla type insurrection. In Ethiopia, I really don't know. You know better about that.

I agree though, that Ethiopians would've eventually overthrown the dergue but how long it would've taken them is just gonna be a guessing game & an exercise in futility.


WAKENI
Member
Posts: 45
Joined: 13 Dec 2014, 16:38

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by WAKENI » 24 Jun 2020, 15:51

There is no need to explain the defeated TPLF cadres. The majority best DERG fighters was stationed in ERITREA the strategic place. On the other hand TIGRAY is not a strategy place nor important region compare to Eritrea, for thuse there was no real DERG presence in Tigray. Weyane was just local SHIFTA with a lot of noise.


abel qael
Senior Member
Posts: 10765
Joined: 07 May 2007, 03:21
Location: gumamistan

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by abel qael » 25 Jun 2020, 04:29

QinXiram Kintarotam Hamasenay lootiew b'ushtin revulsion kuwasmeda hamedgibi eyeru fiyamenta digitalweyane abdesa, etc: You bi'tch, I'm 100% sure you know it is the gallant weyane that liberated Tigray in 1989 on its 15th anniversary , a time when the sh'i'ntam Hamasenays were hiding in naqifan caves during their 28th anniversary. If tigray was not freed 2 years before Mengistu fled, TPLF could not have advanced on Gonder, Wello, Gojam Shewa, etc and finally defeated Dergue. 50% of the soldiers placed in cursedartera were pulled back to tigray and Ethiopia by Mengistu trying to defend himself from TPLF onslaught. The remaining soldiers in [deleted] went to Sudan through the so called "liberated" ar'tera. So where was the werada sh'i'ntam shabia army? You bi'tch terewaee Hamasenays will lie till you die.
Last edited by abel qael on 25 Jun 2020, 04:42, edited 1 time in total.

Digital Weyane
Member+
Posts: 8489
Joined: 19 Jun 2019, 21:45

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Digital Weyane » 25 Jun 2020, 04:39

ሃሪሰ ነይረ ተባራቢረ
ጦረይ ሰዲደ ክወረኪ ኢለ
ምስ ዘየግኔኹኪ ኳራንቲንግ ኮይነ
ንዒ'ባ ዓባይ ትግራይ አዋግዕኒ

wegri
Member
Posts: 913
Joined: 23 Feb 2013, 05:49

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by wegri » 25 Jun 2020, 06:45

Digital Weyane wrote:
25 Jun 2020, 04:39
ሃሪሰ ነይረ ተባራቢረ
ጦረይ ሰዲደ ክወረኪ ኢለ
ምስ ዘየግኔኹኪ ኳራንቲንግ ኮይነ
ንዒ'ባ ዓባይ ትግራይ አዋግዕኒ
DW,
ኣታዮ ሃሳስ ብወያነ የትቐልድይ፡ ሃሪሰ ኔረ እላበልካ ልደብረጽዮን ተብሽቖ እንሄኻ። ስርዓት እንተ ለይገበርካማ ልኽቡር ደብሪጽ ከም ለቐየምካ ተቖጺሩ ልመዋእልካ ውህኒ-ቤት ክትሓልፋ ኢኻ።
እዙይ ላይመጠረሽታ ማጠንቀቕያኡ! :mrgreen:

Ethoash
Senior Member+
Posts: 26144
Joined: 20 Apr 2013, 20:24

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by Ethoash » 25 Jun 2020, 07:20

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) wrote:
25 Jun 2020, 03:49
እነዚህ ጫማ በቅጡ የሌላቸው ሚስኪን የሚመስሉ ወያኔዎች ናቸው ፵ ዓመት ሻቢያ የሞተበትን ጦርነት ቀምቶ ። ለሻቢያ ኤርትራን ብቻ ስጥቶ ለራስ ሲቆርሱ አያሳንሱ በማለት መላውን ኢትዬዽያ መውስዱና ድንገት ችግር ከመጣ አርትክል ፫፱ አስቀምጠው ፴ ዓመት አማራን ቀጥቅጠው ገዙ ይህንን ነው ሞኞች የምትላቸው። በግልፅ ሻቢያ ጃላጅል መሆናቸውን ለአለም ማሳወቃቸው ግልፀ እየሆነ።

ልክ እንደሞኝ ሻቢያ እኔ ነው የደማሁት፣ የሞትኩት ፣ የቆስልኩት ግን ኬኩን የበላው ወያኔ ነው ምንም ሳይስሩ። ከዚህ በላይ ወያኔ ምን ይጫወትባቹሁ እናንተ ገገሞች። አንድ ገበሬ አመቱን በሙሉ መሬቱን አርሶ እኔ አንድ ኩንታል ጤፍ ነው የሚበቃኝ ብሎ ። የተቀረውን መሬት ለውያኔዎች ስጥቶ ። ወያኔዎቹ ደግሞ የደረስውን ጤፍ አጭደው ባለፎክ ቢሆኑ ማን ነው ሞኝ።

ግጥም አርጎ ገብቶቹሀል ግን ለማደናበር ደርግን የጣለው ማነው ትሉናላቹሁ። የደርግን ስልጣንን ማን ተቀበለው ነበር ትክክለኛ መልስ።


wegri
Member
Posts: 913
Joined: 23 Feb 2013, 05:49

Re: Derg was defeated by EPLF (Shabia). If TPLF wants to fight, the war will be against the entire Ethiopian society!

Post by wegri » 25 Jun 2020, 08:11

:lol: :lol: :mrgreen: :lol: :lol: ሕልሚ ዓባይ ትግራይ!

Kuasmeda wrote:
25 Jun 2020, 07:54
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) wrote:
25 Jun 2020, 03:49


Post Reply