Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum
Post Reply
Posts: 2250
Joined: 19 May 2019, 18:02

"COME and SEE" PFDJ Members Caught in a Lie by White Tourists

Post by pastlast » 14 Jan 2020, 01:42

Posts: 2250
Joined: 19 May 2019, 18:02

Re: "COME and SEE" PFDJ Members Caught in a Lie by White Tourists

Post by pastlast » 14 Jan 2020, 01:49

Why Did I Travel to Eritrea?
I was waiting with publishing my post on Eritrea for months now. I wasn’t sure if I should focus just on my in-country experience, as after I included some fact on the actual situation in Eritrea on my Instagram posts, I apparently made some Eritreans feel uneasy.

Some people didn’t like the fact that I talked about the bad situation in Eritrea instead of just focusing on only the good parts I experienced as a visitor. Because let me be clear, Eritreans are wonderful people and their country is beautiful.

That said, I decided that in order to give people a glimpse of Eritrea I need to talk about both aspects. After all, if I didn’t I probably would have offended others who’d say that I’m not talking about a bigger picture.

Where is Eritrea?
Eritrea is one of the most mysterious countries in the world. Most people don’t even know about its existence, or what’s really going on inside the country. Media also rarely reports on the in-country situation, with the exception of last week’s news. For 2 decades, little besides soldiers, refugees and rebels moved across Ethiopia and Eritrea’s closed border, but today the once-barren no man’s land teems with activity.

If you Google Eritrea, you generally won’t find much information about it. If you check news sites, there will be just a few articles about Eritrea, mostly covering the difficult situation of the Eritrean refugees abroad or the concerns regarding human rights there.

A primary school in Asmara, Eritrea.
Despite the lack of news one thing is clear – Eritrea is not Wakanda, it’s actually the opposite. It has the highest amount of refugees in the world, with over 1000 people leaving the country every month and 80% of Eritreans not happy with their life situation. With the country not actually being at war, one should ask why?

However, most people rarely ask about Eritrea while the world’s attention is focused on countries like Syria, North Korea, or Palestine. Ironically, the situation for Eritreans is often worse. Not without reason, the HRW calls Eritrea the North Korea of Africa.

View of Asmara, Eritrea
Why Did I Travel to Eritrea?
I’ve been intrigued by the lack of information about Eritrea, and the research proved to be the toughest I’ve ever done on any country. Almost all academic books published on Eritrea are written by researchers who have never actually visited Eritrea. When I attended a lecture on Eritrea at Georgetown University the professor showed us a documentary on Eritrea, but neither the professor nor the producers of the documentary ever visited the country.

Asmara, Eritrea
Meghan Markle advocated for the situation in Eritrea at One Young World, but also never made it to Eritrea. It stunned me that the majority of researchers and advocates based their information on relations from Eritrean refugees and no one ever tried to enter the country, undercover or not.

Based on my past experience working on women’s rights in Mexico, I knew that when it comes to topics concerning human rights, we can often experience a discourse between academic research and practical in-country investigation. I made it my mission that if I’m ever to speak on human rights issues in Eritrea, I need to see the full picture.

I had to see Eritrea with my own eyes, so I stayed quiet about the trip in order to obtain a visa. It’s not easy to travel to Eritrea and even harder to travel around Eritrea (and it actually became even harder after I left the country), but thanks to traveling in a group I experienced almost no issues.

The bus we traveled in around parts of Eritrea.
After what I saw, learned and knew from other sources, if I had to describe Eritrea in one word I’d say ‘complicated’. Any researcher will tell you that Eritrea is one of the most isolated and repressive countries in the world, with young people having no future. Their choice is to undertake compulsory national service or try to flee. If you don’t do your research beforehand and go to Eritrea because you want to tick all the countries from your list, or visit ‘difficult’ countries, as a tourist you will experience a sugar-coated experience.

boy in Eritrea

But is Eritrea isolated in terms of access to information and situation outside of Eritrea? Not anymore these days. Definitely not as much as Iran or Cuba. In cafes in Asmara, you can see BBC World News or CNN being on most of the time. While Internet is not as widely available as in the Western World, there are many cafes that are always full of people. While it’s incredibly slow and certain things work for certain devices (for some reason I got everything to load and once after 20 minutes I was even able to upload a photo to Instagram), locals mostly watch movies and videos there.

Cafe in Asmara, Eritrea.
National Service in Eritrea
Local guides will never admit to you what’s actually happening. They’re hired to tell you things the government wants tourists to hear about Eritrea. For instance, Eritrea has a compulsory national service for men and women. Conscripts often work 72-hour weeks in extremely harsh conditions with inadequate food and low pay. No one can legally take a leave, which depends on the whim of commanding officers and some report going years without being allowed to visit home. If a conscript fails to return after taking leave, their parents may be jailed until they do. And by jail, it often means a shipping container in the middle of nowhere which one guard actually informally admitted to my group.

To tourists and outside Eritrea, the national service is known to last about 1 to 6 years. I kept asking locals about the length of the national service and every time I was receiving a different answer. 2 years, 5 years, 10 years, 27 years. My local guide, as friendly as she was, claimed that the service lasts 1 year and everyone WANTS to do it to learn about the military. I don’t blame her for not telling me about something that could get her in trouble.

Cafe in Asmara, Eritrea
One person from my group asked me: why do you keep asking this question about the length of military service? Simply because I wanted to see how many people are willing to open up. Some did, mostly those who lived abroad, got another passport, and returned to Eritrea many years later.

One man I spoke to, after he realized that no one around him spoke English, told me that the national service can keep you as long as they want to keep you there. They pay every person a ration of 1000 nakfa per month, and to put this into a perspective a dinner at the restaurant costs 120-200, while a small bottle of water in a store is 12 Nakfa. Not without a reason their national service is not only described by UN and Human Rights Watch as non-community voluntary thing but often slavery.

Report this ad

Tank graveyard near Asmara, Eritrea. People who guard this graveyard live in those containers in the background.
Can People Flee Eritrea Then?
As Africa’s most secretive state and the source of tens of thousands of migrants who have fled towards Europe, fleeing often isn’t as easy. Even if someone gets out of Eritrea, that could be just the beginning of their troubles. The kidnapping of refugees is happening way too often in countries neighboring Eritrea. You won’t read about in the news apart from very rare articles, but there are various organizations helping families of kidnapped women and girls pay the ransom required. If no one pays, they get raped and tortured over and over again. If they happen to make it all the way to Israel, they often get deported to Rwanda.

Report this ad

National Day Parade in Eritrea
Living Conditions in Eritrea
Even as a tourist in Eritrea, you shouldn’t expect luxury. Hotels are very basic, but with normal beds and hot water in the shower. My hotel in Asmara even had air conditioning. Many locals don’t have the same privileges though, especially those living outside of Asmara.

Report this ad

Asmara vs the rest of the country gives an impression of capital vs district 13 in Hunger Games. The capital has beautiful buildings with modern Italian architecture and perfect asphalt roads. There are some cute restaurants, colorful ice cream stores, gorgeous cinemas and I even went to a bowling alley (human/kids operated, but still a bowling alley). It’s very different from most African cities and if a tourist visits just Asmara they’d think that life is wonderful there. The moment you leave the capital you can see how most people truly live. You’ll see houses made of clay, people living in cardboard or steel boxes, often partially destroyed.

Church in Asmara, Eritrea

Report this ad

As I saw first-hand, quite often four women can share one room despite having a job and working more hours than we might when working full-time.

Strolling through the town of Massawa, you can see how gorgeous it used to be, but a lot of it got destroyed during the Eritrean War of Independence from Ethiopia, as The Battle of Massawa was very brutal. Ethiopians used napalm bombs bought from Israel to bomb civilians and the city. Some of the Massawan coral buildings are still standing, but a gorgeous Turkish bank got bombed and mostly destroyed. There are still people living in the old town, using the remaining buildings as a shelter.

Report this ad

Massawa, Eritrea
Friendly Eritreans
Don’t think that despite hard living conditions locals don’t try to enjoy their lives. They make the most of everything and it’s quite refreshing to see. On a Saturday there were so many locals on the beach in Massawa, playing games and enjoying themselves. This pet camel was there for everyone to take photos with before it went home apparently.

Report this ad

While after visiting several African countries I must say that Eritreans are some of the friendliest people I’ve encountered. I felt it from the minute I got on a plane to the capital Asmara where I was the only tourist. I immediately felt welcome and could sense a community between fellow Eritreans who were coming to visit their motherland.

Meeting a friendly camel in Eritrea.

Report this ad

When visiting Keren for a special religious festival, I sat down with a group of guys from my group. When a local family saw that we had nothing to picnic with, they immediately shared their bread with us. Another person offered us coffee. They didn’t want us to sit there while they were eating, even though they didn’t have much themselves.

Another day my friend and I got caught in the rain. We were hiding under the roof of a closed cinema when two girls waved at us and invited us into their home and offered coffee. With the little English they knew, they told us their stories and wanted us to feel welcome.

These gestures were so simple and human, yet, in the Western World they’ve unfortunately stopped being normal. For example, when was the last time you invited a stranger into your home from off the street?

Friendly locals in Keren, Eritrea. * Yes, they did want me to take this photo and were fine with posting this.*

Report this ad

That said, despite the situation Eritrea is a beautiful and amazing country in a tough situation. I’m not saying that I have learned everything there is to know about the country, as I barely scratched the surface, but I’m glad I traveled to Eritrea and met so many friendly locals. I’ve always felt welcomed warmly and never really felt unsafe as a visitor. If you decide to visit Eritrea try to learn about the history and resiliency of the Eritrean people.

READ MORE ON: How to Visit Eritrea

Questions? Thoughts? Let me know in the comment section below!

Share this:
Like this:

Report this ad

CategoriesAfrica, Eritrea, Travel with Purpos

Posts: 2250
Joined: 19 May 2019, 18:02

Re: "COME and SEE" PFDJ Members Caught in a Lie by White Tourists

Post by pastlast » 14 Jan 2020, 01:52

Oct 24, 2019 at 7:48 am | Reply
Thank you for presenting “both sides”. It’s such a tragedy that after so many years of war, Eritreans are oppressed and worse in their own land. I’d like to visit a free Eritrea some day soon, where people did not need to flee in order to survive or have any freedom.

Posts: 1672
Joined: 16 Feb 2013, 01:19

Re: "COME and SEE" PFDJ Members Caught in a Lie by White Tourists

Post by Follower » 14 Jan 2020, 10:37

ዝም በል ለኽባጥ ዓጋመ።


ተጋሩ ደቂ አንስትዮና ኩለን ሓንቲ ከይቀረየት ላብ የመን ላብ ሊብያ ላብ ዓዲ ዓረብ ስለዝተሰደዳ፣ መሻኪን ተጋሩ የሕዋተይ ጉንዲ ምውጋር ጀሚሮም። እዙይስ የሐዝንይ'ዶ ዋይ! ዋይ! ዋይ! ዋይ!

Posts: 901
Joined: 21 Aug 2013, 11:51

Re: "COME and SEE" PFDJ Members Caught in a Lie by White Tourists

Post by YAY » 15 Jan 2020, 05:00

Dear Tourists: Come and See Eritrea, no matter what

Eritrea(ns) are not afraid of the truth, though some may not be outgoing or bitter because of life experiences. Observe both sides. Eritrea has been, of course, complicated, but interesting, and the people are beautiful. Eritrea needs to enhance its visa processing method and encourage visitors to come in.
Eritrea remains one of the least visited countries in the world for a reason. The visa isn’t the easiest to obtain and just this year, it became even harder. On top of the visa issues, in order to travel anywhere outside of the capital – Asmara, or attend national events you need each individual permit. These permits aren’t the easiest to obtain due to the country’s bureaucracy and they’re often rejected.
But don’t let this stop you.Eritrea is a country with friendly locals and as a tourist, you don’t have to worry about safety.

Casual visitors and curious observers are all welcome. See some comments shared:

Oct 22, 2018 at 8:01 pm | Reply

Once I started reading this post, I could not stop until I finished. Great article! I’m glad you shared both sides and your own experiences.
Mar 19, 2019 at 4:02 am | Reply

You white folks are not wanted in Eritrea or anywhere else in Africa, go back to the caves of Europe.
Steve Whiteman
Mar 19, 2019 at 5:31 pm | Reply

ok STEVE :)))
Efrem Elifo
Sep 3, 2019 at 8:08 pm | Reply

I don’t understand why are you being hateful while your last name is “Whiteman”!
Oct 24, 2019 at 7:48 am | Reply

Thank you for presenting “both sides”. It’s such a tragedy that after so many years of war, Eritreans are oppressed and worse in their own land. I’d like to visit a free Eritrea some day soon, where people did not need to flee in order to survive or have any freedom.
Jan 11, 2020 at 3:44 am | Reply

Thanks for accurately describing the Eritrean situation. Btw, it is ‘Prison Break’ that most of the young watch at the internet cafes. Just to learn how to escape from the giant prison called Eritrea
Oct 22, 2018 at 11:21 pm | Reply

Great article about a place that I had never even thought about visiting. Interesting to hear about the situation there and amazing that you went the length to get the true story about what it’s like.
Oct 23, 2018 at 4:01 am | Reply

Wow !! Too brave, to go , to any African or Islamic country. Many criminals & deceivers $$, around them. I even got cheated,,some, from a Uganda Af., couple. And, much, a USA friend, from Kenia Af. I think you over expose, for a vanity foolishness. But its, your life, and I’m, sorry for you. God has keep you well, and I hoppe, He continues doing it, for you and your husband Matt. Because Life is very precious, ( as your person is ), to take that and other risks , that you have taken . Even traveling is an unnecesary risk 🙁 . ( I write you this, because of the appreciation to you both, through your ig postings, hopping , will do some good ).
Renuka Walter
Oct 23, 2018 at 6:43 pm | Reply

You are right, I had never heard of Eritrea until I stumbled upon this blog post. Well, it looks like a nice city. And, I’m glad to know that you really explored it deeply. There are some hard facts about the country that you came up with. It was definitely not a usual travel experience for you.
Oct 26, 2018 at 8:19 pm | Reply

Wow, what a great article! Thank you for reminding us of the excitement of getting out of our comfort zones and showing us such a different place. I’ve really enjoyed reading it throughout. Thanks 🙂
Oct 26, 2018 at 10:38 pm | Reply

I love reading posts like this! It really transports you to a different place. So today, I could experience a bit of Eritrea thanks to you and your travels, thanks!
Oct 27, 2018 at 5:23 pm | Reply

Of course, you somehow managed to find a beach camel again… 🙂

Loved this write-up! It’s nice to get a glimpse of what it’s like to travel to these lesser-known countries.
Ella Mac
Oct 29, 2018 at 11:10 am | Reply

Thanks for writing this awesome article and examples helped alot..please keep on writing
Thank you for sharing information with us.
Adam Hales
Oct 31, 2018 at 11:51 am | Reply

The places you have mentioned are the very best. Thanks for sharing such a nice information
Julia Larson
Nov 1, 2018 at 7:30 pm | Reply

I have never heard of Eritrea either before reading this post. It’s amazing that you exploring and documenting all of these interesting places around the world.
Ava Mac
Nov 2, 2018 at 10:18 am | Reply

Informative article! Thanks for sharing such an useful Information. This is truly a great read for me!! Once again, thanks for the quality articles you post on your blog
Riley @ Riley's Roves
Nov 14, 2018 at 2:19 pm | Reply

Wow! What a great post about a nearly unheard of destination. Thanks for all of your advice and information.
Nov 15, 2018 at 9:20 am | Reply

I loved reading this article…So much to learn about Eritrea..Thank you for sharing !!
Yosef Debessay
Dec 8, 2019 at 6:49 am | Reply

What an interesting article. Thanks for introducing our country and the situation so genuinely .It is in deed a scratch of the facts that in the country is really happening as you said, but simply wonderful presented.
A great appreciation and admiration for your efforts from an Eritrean living in abroad.
Dec 3, 2018 at 9:04 am | Reply

Nice Blog . You have shared lot of information about Eritrea. Thank you.
Dec 6, 2018 at 4:06 am | Reply

This is an interesting article! Thank you for sharing about your experience in Eritrea!
Philemon Kesete
Feb 24, 2019 at 7:45 am | Reply

Wonderful Article about Eritrea. I couldnt agree more.
Feb 27, 2019 at 5:47 pm | Reply

great article! Do you have contact details you are willing to share for local guides etc?
Feb 27, 2019 at 6:40 pm | Reply

The company is called Asmara Grande.
Mar 1, 2019 at 1:22 pm | Reply

Hey Anna, I am well familiar with Eritrean pro-government Twitter trolls. It seems that their comments are roughly split in two: if you post something positive about anything, they retweet endlessly thank you for showing Eritrea as it “really is”, whatever that means – if not, then lo and behold, it will be a Twitter war. I have had many such entertaining discussions. Nice article, though not sure it was a Turkish bank that got bombed in Massawa. Did you mean Banca d’Italia?

On another note, I love your blog name. My name is also Anna, and my page name is along the same lines! : )
Mar 4, 2019 at 11:13 am | Reply

There always seems to be comparison with other African nations when discussing Eritrea. We’re all unique in our own way and I don’t see the need to compare. That being said, Eritreans are friendly and dignified.
Mar 5, 2019 at 7:34 pm | Reply

I am proud of you may dear to visit to my lovely country .
Mar 27, 2019 at 8:29 am | Reply

Loved this post! So many great things
thanks for sharing such a useful information.
Barry Ingenthron
May 18, 2019 at 9:00 am | Reply

I dated a young lady from Eretria. She was a wonderful, kind and loving woman. She managed to move to Canada. She had shared experiences that she had from the war with Ethiopia. It’s sad to see such wonderful people have such horrible experiences in their own country. She truly loves her country. God bless them all. I hope their conditions improve.
Jul 3, 2019 at 7:00 pm | Reply

Hello, as I read this story, I was thinking to myself this is a pretty shallow observation of Eritrea. But at the end of the article you have come to admit that you “barely scratched the surface” and I respect you for that because that is exactly what you did, although some of your claim is factually wrong and pretty much a repeat of the accusation that all those “researchers” that never set foot in the country accused the Eritrean government of. You in fact went farther and make a bold claim saying “80% of Eritreans not happy with their life situation”, according to who? This type of baseless tourist observation is that gets propagated and a false portrait of a country is painted. Thank you for sharing your experience all the same.
Jul 16, 2019 at 10:42 pm | Reply

I went to Eritrea last year and took my kids. We had a great. My 11 yr old son said its the place he likes best as he felt at home there. We went to keren, Asmara, and Massawa. We paid a local fishermen to take us out to a desert island in the red sea. We visited the tank graveyard and the metal market. Eritrean people are beautiful.
Aug 23, 2019 at 12:31 am | Reply

Thank you for sharing your experiences, Anna. I was searching for information about Eritrea after coming across information on another site stating that the country (which I had never heard of) is one of the 4 highest sources of human slavery on Earth. Complicated indeed.
Economic hardships and desperate grasps at personal security and higher standing by governing persona who likely are trying to do the best they know how is a frustrating situation to contemplate from another reality. One where the overloads are motivated by corporate gain.
Thanks again for allowing me to add to my knowledge concerning this region. Very beautiful of you to care and take the time. Many blessings : )
James, in Canada
Sep 15, 2019 at 6:35 am | Reply

Not certain if you’d be able to answer, but I am interested in following the path of ‘Gazelle Force’ during World War II, but I know travel outside of Asmara, Massawa, and Keren is restricted. How would I be able to organize a road trip from Wachai > Keru > Agordat > Keren > Asmara > Massawa if it is indeed possible to do so. Thank you for any information you may be able to provide.
Sep 16, 2019 at 2:02 pm | Reply

Have you seen my other post on traveling to Eritrea – It’s possible to do your route, but you need to get permits through the local company.
Oct 10, 2019 at 7:55 pm | Reply

Thank you for visiting my home land …🇪🇷 👏🏼
Sara Haile
Dec 7, 2019 at 6:55 pm | Reply

Anna, definitely you will be welcomed to Eritrean house anytime. Your report and observation are accurate, thank you for sharing your experience.

Post Reply